Monday, April 29, 2013

Corrections

Perhaps unsurprisingly, news organizations really make you work to find their corrections online.  No matter how I tried I was unable to find any corrections section on the Union Leader's website, for example.  Here's 3 I did find.


The Globe, of all the sites I visited, definitely seems the most forthright and willing to accept and fix mistakes.  "Newspapers are produced by human beings, and human beings make mistakes, particularly with the urgency of time and deadlines, despite how hard we try to get things right. Sometimes it's a reporting error or an editing error," they write.

The Globe also breaks down corrections into 5 categories:

a. A correction corrects erroneous information - a wrong figure, a wrong name or title, for example. The reason for the error is usually stated: e. g. , a reporting error, editing error, or incorrect information given to the paper.
b. A clarification expands or provides more information, to straighten out misinterpretations of what was published and, therefore, reduce confusion or misunderstanding. Ambiguous phrasing is also rectified under this category.
c. An omission is the label for information that for any reason was dropped from an article, e. g. , missing lines.
d. An amplification is used for stories in which information that would have been useful to the reader was inadvertently left out.
e. An Editor's Note contains explanations that do not fall under the other categories, such as a transmission failure or a computer breakdown that prevented something from getting into the paper.
SMG doesn't list any kind of policy regarding corrections, but allows readers to submit any suggestions with the above online form.
Again, couldn't find a "policy" to speak of.  But they do make past corrections easy to find online with the above site.
I find it interesting that the Globe, by far the paper that is most well known of these 3 (likely the most respected as well), really spells out its correction policy very clearly for the reader.  The folks at the Globe seem to want to make absolutely sure that readers know that they take errors and the subsequent revision of those errors very seriously.  
Bangor Daily News' corrections were also admirable, since they make them highly visible on the site. Other than the Globe and BDN, I was unimpressed by the corrections sections for other papers' websites.  As I said, with some like the Union Leader, I couldn't find any such section.  One thing I learned is that to be respected, a news org must not try to appear infallible   Owning up to mistakes and remaining transparent are important, and the Globe does the best job of that.
My corrections policy:
Here at Jake's Daily Bugle, we strive to bring you, the reader, the most reliable and trustworthy local news possible.  We acknowledge, however, that occasionally mistakes, misspellings, and sometimes plain human error will find its way into our pages.  We ask that if you should spot such an error, please email us at corrections@jdb.com.
Our readers and their trust are of paramount priority here at the Bugle.  Mistakes brought to our attention will be fact checked, and printed in the following issue on page 2 in the "Corrections" section.

No comments:

Post a Comment