Monday, April 29, 2013

Worst corrections

For whatever reason, no corrections are currently listed on the Boston Globe's corrections page.  Neither can you find any from Seacoast Media Group.  But on the Bangor Daily News' site, corrections are made clear.  Based on their list of recent corrections, it seems to me that the most common mistakes are simple misspellings or slip-ups involving names, streets, businesses, etc...

Here are some that I found that seem rather run-of-the-mill:

1. A photo caption on a previous version of this story referred to Stagecoach Road. It is Range Road.

2. A previous version of this story misspelled Cory Farley's name. The information was erroneously provided to the BDN.

3. An earlier version reported that Michael Doherty of Lewiston went missing. It is Daniel Doherty.

4. An earlier version of this story contained an error. The chef who launched A Little Somethin’ Sweet bakery in Portland is named Adam Beckworth, not Beckwith.

5. A previous version of this story incorrectly identified Will Blodgett as Will Ambrose.

As is apparent in these corrections, the BDN rarely seems to attribute the source of the error, except in the case of #2.

Some of the worst I could find online:

This one (or these I should say) seems obvious after we followed the misleading reports that flowed following the Boston Marathon Bombing. 

This is a cool list of some of 2012's worst errors.  I distinctly remember the CNN Supreme Court error. 

Corrections

Perhaps unsurprisingly, news organizations really make you work to find their corrections online.  No matter how I tried I was unable to find any corrections section on the Union Leader's website, for example.  Here's 3 I did find.


The Globe, of all the sites I visited, definitely seems the most forthright and willing to accept and fix mistakes.  "Newspapers are produced by human beings, and human beings make mistakes, particularly with the urgency of time and deadlines, despite how hard we try to get things right. Sometimes it's a reporting error or an editing error," they write.

The Globe also breaks down corrections into 5 categories:

a. A correction corrects erroneous information - a wrong figure, a wrong name or title, for example. The reason for the error is usually stated: e. g. , a reporting error, editing error, or incorrect information given to the paper.
b. A clarification expands or provides more information, to straighten out misinterpretations of what was published and, therefore, reduce confusion or misunderstanding. Ambiguous phrasing is also rectified under this category.
c. An omission is the label for information that for any reason was dropped from an article, e. g. , missing lines.
d. An amplification is used for stories in which information that would have been useful to the reader was inadvertently left out.
e. An Editor's Note contains explanations that do not fall under the other categories, such as a transmission failure or a computer breakdown that prevented something from getting into the paper.
SMG doesn't list any kind of policy regarding corrections, but allows readers to submit any suggestions with the above online form.
Again, couldn't find a "policy" to speak of.  But they do make past corrections easy to find online with the above site.
I find it interesting that the Globe, by far the paper that is most well known of these 3 (likely the most respected as well), really spells out its correction policy very clearly for the reader.  The folks at the Globe seem to want to make absolutely sure that readers know that they take errors and the subsequent revision of those errors very seriously.  
Bangor Daily News' corrections were also admirable, since they make them highly visible on the site. Other than the Globe and BDN, I was unimpressed by the corrections sections for other papers' websites.  As I said, with some like the Union Leader, I couldn't find any such section.  One thing I learned is that to be respected, a news org must not try to appear infallible   Owning up to mistakes and remaining transparent are important, and the Globe does the best job of that.
My corrections policy:
Here at Jake's Daily Bugle, we strive to bring you, the reader, the most reliable and trustworthy local news possible.  We acknowledge, however, that occasionally mistakes, misspellings, and sometimes plain human error will find its way into our pages.  We ask that if you should spot such an error, please email us at corrections@jdb.com.
Our readers and their trust are of paramount priority here at the Bugle.  Mistakes brought to our attention will be fact checked, and printed in the following issue on page 2 in the "Corrections" section.

Sunday, April 28, 2013

Revisiting my credo

My original credo:

Always do the right thing, as you see it.  Take into account the feelings and interests of others, but above all else remain true to yourself and your morals. This is not to say you should not stretch beyond your comfort level, or that the advice of others is useless, but always do what seems the most right to you when making important decisions.  

Avoid harsh judgments of others if possible.  Live and let live.  Everyone is just another person trying to make it through life.

Looking back at this credo that I wrote at the beginning of the semester, I can honestly say that I would not change it.  I still believe all of these things, and everything in the credo is something I still try to live by.

So, no changes to the original language of the credo.

However, I do think the last few weeks in which we discussed plagiarism and fabrication may prompt me to make this addition to the end:

"While harsh, uninformed judgements are to be avoided, you should always maintain skepticism.  If something seems off, if any detail seems out of place, question it.  It is always better to get it right."

So here is my new credo, in it's entirety:


Always do the right thing, as you see it.  Take into account the feelings and interests of others, but above all else remain true to yourself and your morals. This is not to say you should not stretch beyond your comfort level, or that the advice of others is useless, but always do what seems the most right to you when making important decisions.  

Avoid harsh judgments of others if possible.  Live and let live.  Everyone is just another person trying to make it through life. While harsh, uninformed judgements are to be avoided, you should always maintain skepticism.  If something seems off, if any detail seems out of place, question it.  It is always better to get it right.





Meeting with reporter

I forgot to mention that last Tuesday (4/24) I met again with Mike, my 621 reporter.  We had about a 20-25 minute meeting in which we discussed his most recent article for class and some of the corrections I would make.  I also helped him to generate some question ideas for his upcoming interview with the subject of his profile piece, Professor Wilburn of the UNH english deptartment.

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Thoughts about the Boston Marathon Attacks


Watching yesterday’s events at the Boston marathon unfold while in class was a very bizarre but  interesting learning experience.  It was foremost a sad, tragic day, but for me it also proved incredibly informative.  Being in that classroom, surrounded by a group of people who all care about journalism, about stories, and about news in general, made the tragic events that were occurring into a strangely useful lesson in the chaos that is breaking news. 

Among the group of us in that classroom, we had such an incredibly wide array of information at our disposal: all of our Twitter feeds exploded with new information (some of which was wrong); Facebook clued us in to the whereabouts of people we knew who ran in the marathon, or were in Boston; and the good old TV news kept us informed as well.  It was tragic, sickening, and hard to stomach, yet I found some excitement in watching it unfold and peeling back the layers with all of you through those different mediums. 

In the hours after the bombings, much like the streets of Boston, the world of journalism was temporarily cast into a state of chaos, and directionless speculation.  Some of the information we were exposed to in the waking minutes and hours after the explosions was useful.  Other information was misleading (I’m looking at you, New York Post).  But all of it showed me the different ways we as journalists can respond in the moments following tragic, chaotic breaking news events. 

One technique that was most effective in getting the news out quickly was the use of video, and the widespread exposure of that video through social media.  Boston Globe reporter Steve Silvia’s video capturing the first explosion from the finish line spread like wildfire across Twitter and Facebook, exposing the truest, most raw kind of news to the masses.  There is no speculation, no faulty facts that come along with the video, just the explosion and ensuing chaos as it occurred.  Of course, this is not enough to be the news as there is nothing to inform people of the context of the explosions, but at a time in which nobody knows what is going on, images captured on camera can speak loudest, especially video like this.  To me, videos like Silvia’s were the most compelling pieces of news to come out of yesterday’s attacks.  While they don’t fill in the details or provide much context, they are useful for making the news more tangible.

Of course, the most interesting aspects of Silvia’s video, is that it is not professional looking in any way.  It is clear that he is flustered, overwhelmed by the moment, and just capturing what is happening in front of him.  But this shows the way in which news today can be captured by anyone with a cell phone.  The proliferation of information spreading through social media can make anyone a journalist, as anyone can upload a video to Twitter or Facebook.  

Paramount among the lessons related to journalism that I learned from yesterday’s attacks is that this sort of fast-paced reporting – videos, photos, snippets on information being spread through social media – is truly the most effective way to work in those moments after an event like these bombings. Andy Carvin and others live tweeted after the explosions, providing up-to-the-minute, but carefully reported information. The story is as raw as it will ever be in these moments, and using these technologies it is possible to bring the real news to people rapidly.

In events like yesterday's, capturing the story before the door closes on information is vital, but after that door does close I would imagine it is key to continue asking questions.  Ask people who were on the scene for their stories to try to fill in some of the blanks. In all honesty, I can say that I don't have the answers to this issue.  I've never reported a tragedy or breaking news story, and I have no idea how I would react to that sort of chaos.  I think I would first respond with fear.  From there, I think I would just keep asking questions, and try my best to get in touch with officials that have facts.         

The other important take-away I got from yesterday is similar to what Chris Outcalt harped on in his visiting journalist talk last week: Get it right.  As we learned more about the attacks yesterday, we were deluged with an overwhelming amount of misleading or straight up false information.  The New York Post’s reports of 12 deaths and subsequent backtracking on those reports is a great example of how information can be skewed in times like these.  In a news world that is getting faster and faster, it can be hard to keep up, But getting it wrong is never worth it. 


Monday, April 8, 2013

Headlines, questions

Here is the story I read for the assignment.

Print headline:

Son-in-law of murdered police chief requests trial

Online headline:

Slain officer's former kin
asks trial on drug charges

Six questions:

1. Visual story? - This is not an overly visual story, but it lends itself to images of those involved.  The mugshot of Nieves is very telling of his character. Perhaps online, this could include shots of Maloney, Cullen Murtie, and shots of the house where Mutrie killed Maloney.  These photos would create the opportunity for readers to recallthe context of that incident, which is really the only reason why Nieves' story is news. Also, video of any news stories covering that murder would add further context.

2.   Complex? Background? -  The story is relatively complex, because it really asks the reader to understand the background of Chief Maloney's murder.  To allow for context, links to that original story would be greatly helpful. Make Maloney's name the link so that readers can jump right to that story for context should they require it.

3. Time Sensitive? - It doesn't seem that this story is particularly time sensitive, since it dates all the way back to August when Nieves was arrested, and there is still a while until he will be tried.  

4. Reader involvement? - Click here  

5.  Serious or fun? - This is most definitely a serious story.  Not much fun to be had with murder, drugs, and weapons. 

6. Location? - Location does play a role in this story, albeit not a very interesting one.  Perhaps some sort of graphic that shows on a map where each part of this story took place: the slaying of Maloney, Nieves' arrest, etc... But that might not really work well. 




Reader response?

Readers -   What do you take away from Nieves quote that Mutrie "should have shot more officers"?  How did Nieves get involved in the family of a police chief in the first place?

Monday, April 1, 2013

State of the Media 2013

The most pressing aspect of The State of the News Media report for editors, reporters, and journalism as a whole is that of journalism's financial state.  As the overview made very clear, the intense decreases in financial stability that news organizations have been subjected to not only impact the economic survival of those organizations but the credibility of the sources as well.  The fact that nearly a third of US adults have stopped tuning into news sources because of discrepancies between their expectations of these sources and the quality of stories that are actually told is a scary prospect to me.  When I thought about the financial struggles that journalism is undergoing, my thinking was always rather myopic, in that I have always focused on the economic point of view.  "How many jobs will be lost?  How long will journalism be a financially viable career choice?"  Those were the types of questions that I had thought about.  Yet this report introduced a whole new way of thinking.  The quality of that reporting could also be affected by the decreasing resources news organizations are able to acquire.  It seems so naive now, but I can honestly say that I never questioned the integrity of reporting in the face of financial issues.  Obviously, though, that is something journalists need to think about.  The lack of in-depth reporting that went into the 2012 election is one great example of this decline in quality that the report points out.  

It is clear that we have moved much past the point of the internet being a mere fad.  Online news is most definitely the future, and I think that the most prudent of news organizations will make moves toward focusing on the internet as the next frontier in journalism.  Despite the outrage it caused, I believe that the New Orleans newspaper The Times-Picayune made a smart decision in pulling back to printing only 3 issues a week.  Placing focus on their online presence is probably the best way to go at this time.  I think that editors should take note of strategies like this one.  It may seem outrageous and in many ways upsetting, but I believe companies that take risks like the Times-Picayune and move further away from print and closer to online journalism will be rewarded financially in the long term.  

Another tactic to take note of is the digital "pay-wall" or digital pay plans.  News organizations are moving toward decreasing dependence on advertising alone to create income by charging people in order to read online content.  I think that this is an important strategy as well.  As the report states, 

"The problem for news is the composition of the digital ad market, starting with the intensifying competition it faces from Google and other tech firms. While no separate tally breaking out the news industry’s share of digital ads exists, one daunting truth is clear: News is a tiny player in a market dominated by the large technology companies like Google and Facebook. Together, the five largest companies – Google, Yahoo, Facebook, Microsoft and AOL – pocketed 64% of all digital ad spending in the U.S. in 2012, unchanged from 2011."

While digital advertising is a potential solution to the financial problems plaguing journalism, it is clear that it is not the solution since at this point, news does not have a large cut of that market.  For that reason, it is important for news organizations to find a way to develop income from readers.  I believe that the "pay-wall" tactic is a decent start.   

Overall, this report really helped me gain a larger understanding of the current financial state of journalism.  It is indeed a very complex matter to sort out, but if news organizations are to survive, it is a climate that they will have to adapt to.