I compared leads for two stories from these two outlets, the first being a story about former NH state representative Tony Soltani's acquittal on felony charges.
Here's the Concord Monitor's lead:
"A jury this morning found former state representative Tony Soltani of Epsom guilty of misdemeanor charges of reckless and disorderly conduct, but not guilty of a heavier felony charge of reckless conduct, for his role in a police chase last year."
And here is the Union Leader's take:
"A Merrimack County Superior jury Wednesday convicted former Epsom State Rep. Tony Soltani of misdemeanor reckless conduct and disorderly conduct for his actions in joining a police chase last April."
All things considered, both leads seem to get the job done. Both are standard summary leads. Neither one really varies too drastically from the other. In a breaking news story like this one, however, this is mostly what I would have expected. It is difficult to choose which of these two leads I find more effective since they are so similar. It is interesting to note that the Union Leader chose to ignore the charge that Soltani was acquitted on in their lead, only including information about his conviction in the opening paragraph. This decision to leave that information out of the lead could show the paper's leanings toward a more stringent, conservative justice policy.
I also took a look at some different leads from larger news outlets on the breaking news story about Jesse Jackson Jr.'s guilty plea to the misuse of campaign funds. I took a look at Fox News, CNN, and the New York Times' takes on the story.
Here's CNN's:
"Dabbing at his eyes with a handkerchief, former U.S. Rep. Jesse Jackson Jr. pleaded guilty on Wednesday to one federal charge related to using campaign funds for personal expenses."
And Fox News':
"Former Rep. Jesse Jackson Jr. pleaded guilty Wednesday in federal court to charges that he spent $750,000 in campaign cash on personal items."
The difference between these two leads struck me. CNN takes an almost sympathetic, much more humanizing approach to theirs, by including the color details about Jackson crying during his plea. It isn't a delayed lead by any standard, but it does delay the news much more than the Fox lead (or the NYT lead that I will write about later) Fox News, perhaps unsurprisingly, was much more hardline, and curt about Jackson's plea. In the Fox lead, Jackson's emotions are nowhere to be found. The Fox lead also includes more specifically incriminating details of Jackson's crime than does the CNN lead, as it goes into the exact amount of money that he misused.
And here is the New York Times:
"Jesse L. Jackson Jr., the former Democratic representative from Illinois, pleaded guilty on Wednesday to one count of wire and mail fraud in connection with his use of $750,000 in campaign funds to buy exotic items like fur capes and celebrity memorabilia."
Of the three leads, it makes sense that the New York Times' would be the most expansive paragraph. "All the news that's fit to print," the company's motto seems fitting here, as this lead crams more information in than either of the other two. The details about what the campaign funds were used for are interesting, and it is probably my favorite of these three leads since it is the most informative, and also the most interesting to read. CNN's attempts at color details (Jackson's handkerchief) come off as a little overly sympathetic, or overly touchy, Fox's lead is a bit devoid of the human touch, as it tells the news and only that. The New York Times lead on the other hand takes what both the CNN and Fox leads were going for, combines those ideas, and pulls it off more effectively.
No comments:
Post a Comment